The Console Graveyard: Video Game Movies That Deserved a Franchise (But Died Trying)
In an era where video game adaptations are finally hitting their stride, with critical darlings like HBO’s The Last of Us and box office titans such as The Super Mario Bros. Movie dominating screens, it’s easy to forget the long, often painful journey to this point. For decades, the ‘video game movie curse’ was a very real, palpable threat, dooming even the most beloved IPs to cinematic mediocrity. But beyond the outright disasters, there’s a more poignant category: the films that showed flashes of brilliance, possessed compelling source material, and boasted serious star power, yet still failed to launch the multi-film franchises they arguably deserved. As a senior entertainment journalist, I’ve watched this cycle play out countless times, and the echoes of what could have been still reverberate through Hollywood’s hallowed halls.
It’s a unique kind of heartbreak for fans and filmmakers alike when a project with immense potential gets bogged down by studio interference, muddled narratives, or simply bad timing. These weren’t necessarily universally beloved films, but they contained the seeds of something bigger, something that with a second, third, or even fourth attempt, could have blossomed into a cornerstone of a cinematic universe. Instead, they became cautionary tales, their reputations preceding them and effectively slamming the door shut on any future installments.
Near Misses and Squandered Potential: When Ambition Isn’t Enough
Let’s talk about Assassin’s Creed (2016). When news broke that Michael Fassbender, Marion Cotillard, and director Justin Kurzel (fresh off their acclaimed collaboration on Macbeth) were tackling Ubisoft’s sprawling historical sci-fi saga, industry buzz was electric. The concept – a secret society reliving ancestral memories through a genetic link – was ripe for cinematic exploration. The visuals were stunning, particularly the parkour sequences and the visceral, grounded action. Yet, the film struggled to find its footing with audiences and critics. The convoluted plot, which spent perhaps too much time in the present-day Animus rather than the vibrant 15th-century Spanish Inquisition, left many scratching their heads. Despite a respectable box office take of nearly $240 million worldwide against a $125 million budget, it wasn’t enough to justify a sequel. The potential for a sprawling, interconnected franchise exploring different historical periods was immense, a true competitor to the likes of Indiana Jones or National Treasure, but it was lost. Now, we hear whispers of an Assassin’s Creed TV reboot – a second chance, perhaps, but a stark reminder of the film’s missed opportunity.
Then there’s Warcraft (2016), another victim of high expectations and a muddled production. Directed by the talented Duncan Jones (Moon, Source Code), this adaptation of Blizzard’s legendary fantasy universe had a passionate fanbase ready to flock to theaters. Its visual effects were groundbreaking, bringing the orcs and humans of Azeroth to life with impressive fidelity. However, the film suffered from a fundamental disconnect: it tried to serve both loyal fans and general audiences, arguably pleasing neither entirely. While it flopped domestically, earning only $47 million in North America, it was a massive hit internationally, particularly in China, where it grossed over $213 million. This split performance created an unusual dilemma: a global success that was a domestic failure. Studio Legendary, despite the international numbers, ultimately decided not to move forward with a sequel, citing the massive budget (reportedly $160 million) and the lack of a clear path forward. Many insiders believed Jones had a more ambitious, darker vision that was diluted by studio notes, leaving fans to wonder what a truly uncompromised Warcraft saga could have been.
And let’s not forget Prince of Persia: The Sands of Time (2010). Disney, fresh off the success of Pirates of the Caribbean, poured a reported $200 million into adapting Ubisoft’s popular action-adventure game. With Jake Gyllenhaal leading a solid cast and Jerry Bruckheimer producing, it seemed like a sure bet for a swashbuckling franchise. The film was visually engaging, with impressive parkour and time-bending mechanics. While it earned over $336 million worldwide, it was merely an ‘okay’ performance for a Disney tentpole of that magnitude, especially one with such a hefty price tag. It lacked the undeniable spark and critical acclaim that propelled Pirates into multiple sequels. Despite the solid box office, the generic nature of its plot and a somewhat lukewarm reception meant Disney moved on, leaving Dastan’s adventures unfinished.
Even Good Ones Struggle: The Modern Dilemma
It’s not just about critical consensus or box office anymore; sometimes, even a genuinely good adaptation can struggle to ignite a franchise. Take Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves (2023). Critically acclaimed, beloved by audiences, and boasting a fantastic ensemble cast including Chris Pine and Michelle Rodriguez, it was hailed as one of the best fantasy-adventure films in recent memory. It perfectly captured the spirit of tabletop RPGs, balancing humor, heart, and thrilling action. Yet, despite its quality, the film underperformed at the box office, grossing only $208 million worldwide against a $150 million budget. In today’s climate, where studios demand massive returns to justify multi-picture commitments, even a near-perfect adaptation isn’t always enough to guarantee a franchise, leaving fans clamoring for a sequel that may never come.
Similarly, Tomb Raider (2018), starring Alicia Vikander as a grounded, gritty Lara Croft, received a surprisingly positive critical reception for its more realistic take on the iconic adventurer. It offered a compelling origin story, moving away from the more fantastical elements of previous iterations and Angelina Jolie’s turn. With a worldwide gross of $274 million on a $90 million budget, it was a solid performer, but not a breakout hit. While discussions for a sequel were ongoing, creative differences, studio shifts, and eventually the pandemic stalled any momentum, leaving Vikander’s Lara without a follow-up adventure. It’s a shame, as many felt it laid excellent groundwork for a more mature, compelling series.
What’s Next for Game Adaptations?
The journey from pixels to multiplex has always been fraught with peril. The recent successes of Mario and The Last of Us offer a blueprint: respect the source material, find a passionate creative team, and understand the core appeal. Sometimes, television proves to be a more forgiving and expansive medium for complex game narratives. The ongoing quest for the next big video game cinematic universe continues, but as these examples show, even with the right ingredients, launching a franchise is a delicate, often unpredictable art. For every triumph, there’s a graveyard of promising projects that simply couldn’t get past level one. We’ll be watching closely to see which IPs finally break the mold and which join the ranks of the ‘could have beens’.









